WPA: Pure Evil?
While cruising Slashdot I came across this blog post from Ed Bott about the future of Windows Product Activation. So apparently there is an ugly rumor going around that the Windows Genuine Advantage Notification update will become manditory for all Windows machines this fall. And by mandatory, I mean your computer will stop receiving critical security updates if you don’t have it installed. Check out this response sent to Ed from Microsoft after he inquired about the WPA mess:
As we have mentioned previously, as the WGA Notifications program expands in the future, customers may be required to participate. [emphasis added] Microsoft is gathering feedback in select markets to learn how it can best meet its customers’ needs and will keep customers informed of any changes to the program.
Also there are several other posts and comments talking about the “quality” of the WGA software that is being pushed out with Windows update. Several users reported crashes and/or blue screens, or that their CD-keys were flagged as already in use. Although some of these reports could be anti-Microsoft hate, there could be legitimate reasons to not install WGA on your machine..
I have several questions for Microsoft about this fiasco. First off, why is WGA pushed as a critical Windows update? Up until now participating in the WGA program has been completely optional. Most novice home users will have automatic updates turned on, and by default Windows pulls down critical security updates. How would you feel if you come home from work to find that your computer has been royally screwed by a critical update that is supposed to help you? Better yet what if this program erroneously flags your legal copy of Windows as pirated and gives you 30 days to get legal? The three hours I would spend in the MS Technical Support queue would be a great prep time for my yelling voice ;).
In the end the WPA initiative is making Micro$oft look like the big ugly green giant they truely are. I haven’t installed WPA on my machine, and I probably won’t ever. Even if the “kill switch” is pushed in September. Hell some people I know are running on XP SP1 just fine! My computer will probably be seeing a port to Suse 10.1 Linux in the near future. I’d rather go with software that is built by honest, hard working developers and not the code slaves of the Microsoft mines. So as a user, I charge you to go tell every Windows user you know about Microsoft’s plan. Raise enough ruckus and maybe Microsoft will put the breaks on this very bad idea.